I spent last 2 days attending Develop3D Live conference in Boston. The conference organized by Develop3D is US version of Develop3D Live event in Warwick UK. It gathered few hundred people focusing on engineering and manufacturing technologies – CAD, PLM, 3D printing, etc. I spent most of my time at OpenBOM exhibition stand.
At the same time, I was very interested to listen to presentation of CAD vendors. Cloud CAD and PDM development is one of the topics I’m following for long time already. I covered presentations of Autodesk and Onshape -two CAD vendors that put lot of focus in development of CAD for cloud-based environment. You can catch up on my previous blogs. For example, the following articles: Autodesk and Onshape disagree about cloud-technology and focus; Autodesk Fusion360 and Onshape technological trajectories are getting close; How Fusion360 and Onshape are solving fundamental collaboration problems.
At Develop3D Live, presentations by Solidworks and Solid Edge speaking about cloud CAD development caught by special attention.
Solidworks’ Kishore Boyalakuntla presented videos demonstrating Solidworks X-Design, new CAD system working completely in a browser. The system was per-announced earlier, but this is the most complete video demo I’ve seen so far about X-Design Part modeling and X-Design Assembly .
Solid Edge by Siemens PLM is another product that until very recently was staying a bit aside from cloud development battles.
As you can see from few slides below, Solid Edge strategy is cloud-enable existing desktop product and not to replace it with new browser based product.
On the video below you can see video demo made by Dan Staples, VP of Mainstream Engineering at Siemens PLM showing Solid Edge Collaboration portal.
Solidworks and Solid Edge are demonstrating different strategies. Solidworks is moving to browser and at the same time also to remove their dependence on Siemens PLM Parasolid engine. According to Kishore, Solidworks X-Design is using CGM (Dassault Systemes CATIA geometric modeler). Siemens PLM strategy is to keep Solid Edge as a single product while “cloud enable” it with additional features and also developing separate collaboration portal for neutral CAD collaboration.
What is my conclusion? Solidworks trajectory to develop full browser-based CAD is similar to Onshape. That part of cloud-CAD development story will be very interesting to watch for the next few years. Solidworks will have to keep both desktop Solidworks and new browser based CAD for very long time. From that standpoint Solidworks desktop-browser balance is similar to the one Autodesk has. Opposite to that, Siemens PLM Solid Edge is remaining single CAD system capable to work in both pure desktop and cloud-enabled scenarios. Solid Edge collaboration portal looks like a way for Solid Edge to answer on questions about how to get to CAD data using browser. Next few years will show what strategy will be the winning one. For both Solidworks and Solid Edge the first goal is similar – to protect their install base from being disrupted by new systems such as Onshape and Autodesk Fusion360 and keep growing organically. Watch this space for the next few years. Just my thoughts…
Best, Oleg
Want to learn more about PLM? Check out my new PLM Book website.
Disclaimer: I’m co-founder and CEO of OpenBOM developing cloud based bill of materials and inventory management tool for manufacturing companies, hardware startups and supply chain. My opinion can be unintentionally biased.
